Shelter Island

Today there are still small details present that trace back to the community’s earliest inhabitants.

Welcome to Shelter Island

A private and relaxed area with beautiful natural surroundings and unparalleled homes
An island town in Suffolk County, New York, Shelter Island is a private and relaxed community that is ideal for those who desire a peaceful oasis. A beautiful area that is only accessible by ferry, this island offers a blend of privacy and whimsy for locals to enjoy. The community also has a rich history - initial settlement began in the 1650s, and even today there are still small details present that trace back to the community’s earliest inhabitants. 
Communities on Shelter Island are extremely easygoing and laid-back, which is perfect for those who like to take it slow. Homes here are framed by gorgeous natural surroundings, making this the perfect location where locals can get a mix of both modern amenities as well as still, quiet surroundings. Boasting idyllic single-family homes as well as elegant waterfront manors, there are properties for every preference available here.

What to Love

  • A cool and active community
  • Tons of local restaurants and cafés 
  • Elegant and timeless residences

Local Lifestyle 

Shelter Island locals live a peaceful and laid-back life. Things move at a relaxed pace here, which is ideal for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Common pastimes for residents here include biking through the neighborhood, boating on the still water, and enjoying drinks and dinner with friends. For locals who want to experience more excitement every once in a while, the high-energy social scene of the greater Hamptons area is just a short distance away.

Dining, Entertainment, and Shopping 

Shelter Island and the surrounding Hamptons area offer a wide assortment of culinary options for residents to explore! With everything from small local cafés to refined high-end restaurants, this area provides locals with dreamy dining experiences that they won’t forget. 
One Shelter Island dining favorite is Sunset Beach Restaurant, which is located within the boutique Sunset Beach Hotel. Offering incredible coastal cuisine, this is a wonderful spot to visit for a relaxed weekend dinner or for a stylish late lunch with friends. Menu highlights include the Steamed Pei Mussels, the Local Striped Bass, and the Tagliata New York Strip. Also boasting a robust wine and cocktail selection, this is a fashionable spot that residents love.
Vine Street Café is another fantastic dining destination in the area. Serving classic American dishes in a cozy and approachable setting, this is a wonderful spot for a casual date night or a family dinner. Serving dishes made with locally-sourced ingredients, Vine Street Café ensures guests always receive fresh and tasty meals. Must-try menu items include the Miso Salmon, the Grilled Skirt Steak, and the Mezzi Rigatoni alla Bolognese. 
Shelter Island has plenty of small local businesses that residents love to browse and support. Featuring gift shops, antique stores, home furnishing boutiques, and more throughout the community, Shelter Island is an eclectic retail destination where shoppers can find plenty of unique items.

Things to Do

Shelter Island locals have plenty of things to do during their free time! Many residents enjoy visiting Mashomack Preserve. This nature preserve takes up a large majority of the island, and it is a protected area that flourishes with an array of plants and animals. Perfect for bird-watching, walking, and picnicking, this preserve is a must-see spot for nature lovers.
Locals also enjoy spending time at Coecles Harbor Marina & Boatyard. This beautiful waterfront spot allows visitors to enjoy first-class marina facilities in a peaceful and undisturbed environment. Locals frequent this boatyard, especially when getting ready to sail out onto the calm waters at sunrise or boat through the area with friends on weekend afternoons.


Shelter Island and its surrounding areas have a diverse array of schools for families to consider. Shelter Island High School is one popular option for older students in the area. Boasting an engaging and empowering environment for students to learn and grow in, this is a wonderful option where students can gain a solid personal and academic foundation.
Search All Homes

Contact us to learn more

Contact Susan


Susan’s impeccable service and outstanding results are fueled by her unparalleled market knowledge, sharp negotiating skills and innovative marketing. When you choose Susan to sell your home, you are aligning yourself with the ultimate professional, and assuring yourself the best service and results.

Contact Us

Follow Us on Instagram