238 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
238 Main St

238 Main St

238 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY


  • 7 Beds
  • 8 Full Baths
  • 1 Half Bath
  • 1.1 Sq.Ft. Lot
  • 10,000 Sq.Ft. Living
  • 1833 Year Built
  • Sold Status

The historic Nathan P. Howell house is the largest house on one of the largest lots on renowned Captain's Row and a rare example of period architecture, offering many individual work and private spaces, impeccably renovated to the highest level with original details including the double-hung sash windows, shutters, acanthus leaves, and moldings, expert craftsmanship, fine millwork and trim, antique wide plank floors, and marble mantles. This amazing property is on over an acre, extremely quiet and private and totally landscaped by Marder's, with specimen trees and incredibly unique especially for Sag Harbor Village! Built in 1833 representing Sag Harbor's most elaborate Greek Revival architecture, expanded and remodeled, the main residence offers over 10,000 sf of living space on four levels with seven bedrooms, eight full and one-half baths. Arched entries lead along gracious hallways to grand light-filled parlors with 10-1/2 ft. ceilings. This stylish landmark home also features a superbly appointed epicurean kitchen, nine fireplaces, two staircases, an elevator, and a cupola, with stunning sunsets and views. Situated on over an acre in the heart of the village, the elaborately landscaped grounds and beautiful gardens provide the utmost in privacy and include a gunite pool and a four-bay, climate-controlled garage with separate art studio, with full bath and kitchenette attached.

Show MoreShow Less
Susan Breitenbach

Susan Breitenbach




  • Total Bedrooms7
  • Total Bathrooms8.5
  • Full Bathrooms8
  • Half Bathrooms1

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Living Area10,000 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area1.1 Sq.Ft.
  • YEAR BUILT1833




  • Sales Price$9,500,000


Susan’s impeccable service and outstanding results are fueled by her unparalleled market knowledge, sharp negotiating skills and innovative marketing. When you choose Susan to sell your home, you are aligning yourself with the ultimate professional, and assuring yourself the best service and results.

Contact Us

Follow Us on Instagram