Celebrity Home Listings in the Hamptons: Christie Brinkley and Donald Trump Jr.
Two well-documented Hamptons sales illustrate the celebrity draw to this market: Christie Brinkley's 1843 Sag Harbor mansion sold for approximately $17.9 million in 2019, and a Bridgehampton estate once owned by Donald Trump Jr. and Kimberly Guilfoyle resold for $8.1 million in 2021 after they bought it for $4.4 million in 2019, with Corcoran's Susan Breitenbach involved in both transactions.
Curious what Sag Harbor or Bridgehampton offers beyond the headlines?
See what's currently available in Sag Harbor or Bridgehampton.
Situated on the tip of Long Island, the Hamptons are renowned for their gorgeous estates and vacation getaways. Filled with an array of pristine beaches, world-class shopping, and ultra-luxurious resorts, this legendary string of villages makes for an amazing place to kick back and relax. Whether you are considering a visit or a move to the Hamptons, there are plenty of exciting things to do here. For example, there are beautiful golf courses, classic horse shows, and a diverse variety of five-star restaurants. A highly popular place to vacation and get away from the hustle of everyday life, the Hamptons provide the ultimate experience in luxury.
An exceptional characteristic of these famed and shining towns is that they really do have something special for everyone. From the spectacular art scene to the plethora of recreational activities, there are plenty of reasons to fall in love with the Hamptons. It is filled with historic charm, rural backdrop, and picturesque nature scenes. With an excellent selection of breakfast nooks, endearing boutiques, and cozy coffee shops, the Hamptons have all the perfect ingredients to be your future dream home. Additionally, it is a well-known spot for celebrities who wish to have a break from big city living and relax during the summer months. Here is a look at two well-documented celebrity home sales in the area.
Why Celebrities Enjoy Life in the Hamptons
The serene beaches and lavish estates are just some of the reasons why celebrities flock to the Hamptons. Perhaps one of the most appealing reasons is the ability to withdraw from the busyness of life and go unnoticed. These luxurious towns make the perfect spot for celebrities who want to purchase or rent a home where they can live in relative peace and anonymity. An ideal place to fly under the radar, the Hamptons offer a tranquil pace of life as well as an incredible array of luxurious amenities.
From the breathtaking scenery to the towering lighthouse, there are lots of reasons for celebrities to come here, whether to buy a house and stay a while or rent for a relaxing stay at this natural oasis. Furthermore, the Hamptons are also a hotspot for celebrities to invest in real estate as well. Because of its incredible popularity for resorts and vacations, houses for sale or rent are in high demand.
Undoubtedly, some major attractions of the Hamptons include its stunning homes, riveting natural beauty, and quiet atmosphere. Rated as one of the top ten beaches in America, Cooper's Beach is an ideal spot to unwind after a long day. At this highly sought-after destination, visitors can enjoy the sandy shores and immerse themselves in the scenes of nature. Here you can picnic, surf, or snap pictures of the sparkling waters.
Another draw of the Hamptons is its delectable dining and diverse restaurant options. The 1770 House has a warm and inviting tradition of welcoming guests from around the world. Today this gorgeous house is a restaurant, bar, and inn, serving homestyle American cooking including dishes such as the North African Spiced Quail or the Marinated Veal Rib Chop. Nick & Toni's is open for indoor and outdoor dining. Established in 1988, this pristine restaurant is an amazing place to enjoy a luxurious and laid-back dinner, from delicious pasta dishes to a sparkling selection of drinks.
Interested in Sag Harbor's dining and village scene beyond these two headline sales? See the Sag Harbor neighborhood guide.
Christie Brinkley's Home
Photo courtesy of Susan Breitenbach Real Estate
Model and actress Christie Brinkley sold her Sag Harbor colonial-style mansion in 2019 for approximately $17.9 million, just under its final asking price of $17,999,000, after the price had been reduced from an original 2016 listing of $25 million. Corcoran's Susan Breitenbach represented the buyer. Originally constructed in 1843, this gleaming white mansion consists of 5,500 square feet. It has five bedrooms, a large marble kitchen, study, mudroom, and several dining areas. With intricate details and ornamental 19th-century signatures, this house certainly makes an impression. From its sweeping views of the harbor to its beautiful fireplaces, it is filled with unique charm and history. The wide-plank floors are pine and the banister is made from oak, and the property includes an inground swimming pool.
Sag Harbor itself, the location of Brinkley's mansion, is situated three-fifths in Southampton and two-fifths in East Hampton. The town is widely remembered for its history in the whaling industry and offers a diverse selection of charming shops and scrumptious eateries. Founded in the 1700s, Sag Harbor became an international port and retains its character and warm spirit to this day.
Photo courtesy of Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum
Some notable features include the popular Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, which tells the story of the town's fascinating past. For art lovers, Grenning Gallery is the perfect place to marvel at riveting landscapes, life-like sculptures, and vibrant paintings. Foster Memorial Beach, known as Long Beach, is the go-to place for a refreshing swim, a stroll, or a picnic with family. The quaint village of Sag Harbor is filled with restaurants, the renowned Bay Street Theater, the Sag Harbor Cinema, and stunningly gorgeous homes.
Source: Christie Brinkley's Sag Harbor sale price and Susan Breitenbach's role per Forbes and The Real Deal reporting from 2019; the original figure previously published on this page ($15 million) has been corrected to align with contemporaneous reporting.
Donald Trump Jr.'s Home
Photo courtesy of CNBC
Donald Trump Jr. and Kimberly Guilfoyle purchased a Bridgehampton home in 2019 for $4.4 million, with Susan Breitenbach involved in the transaction. They sold the home in March 2021 for $8.1 million. Later that year, Alex Rodriguez rented the same home for the summer, according to The Real Deal. Made up of 9,200 square feet, the home has seven bedrooms and eleven bathrooms. It sits on nearly four acres of land with a pool and access to a 25-acre pond, and also includes a spa and a waterfall.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do celebrities buy homes in Sag Harbor and Bridgehampton specifically?
Both hamlets offer the combination of relative privacy, historic architecture, and proximity to the ocean and bay that draws high-profile buyers seeking to disconnect from city life while remaining close to New York.
Do these sales reflect typical Hamptons luxury pricing?
These two sales, $17.9 million for a historic Sag Harbor waterfront estate and $8.1 million for a Bridgehampton compound, sit within the range seen across the Hamptons luxury market, where multimillion-dollar transactions are common for estate-scale properties.
Can I see these homes or similar properties?
These specific homes are private residences, but similar Sag Harbor and Bridgehampton properties come to market regularly. Contact Susan Breitenbach to discuss current listings with comparable character and location.
Meet Your Hamptons Guide
Susan Breitenbach is a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker with The Corcoran Group, based out of offices in Southampton and Sag Harbor, and has represented parties in both of the transactions described above. She has spent over 35 years working the Hamptons market from Westhampton to Montauk and has closed more than $6.4 billion in career sales.
Related Reading
- Sag Harbor Neighborhood Guide
- Bridgehampton Real Estate For Sale
- Exploring High-End Homes in the Hamptons
- Best Country Clubs in the Hamptons
Next Steps
Are you considering a move to the Hamptons? If so, there is no better time than now to begin the process of looking for your future home. Enlisting an excellent and knowledgeable real estate agent can make your house-hunting a smooth and seamless process, from finding listings to navigating current real estate trends.
Meet Susan Breitenbach. The epitome of Hamptons luxury real estate, Susan is incredibly respected by her clients for her vibrant work ethic and wealth of knowledge regarding current real estate trends. Through her connections both in the U.S. and overseas, Susan is ready to walk through the house-hunting process with you. Contact her today and take the next step in your journey.
Source Notes: 1. Christie Brinkley's Sag Harbor sale price and history per Forbes ("Christie Brinkley Finally Sells Sag Harbor Mansion For $17 Million") and The Real Deal, 2019. 2. Donald Trump Jr. and Kimberly Guilfoyle's Bridgehampton purchase and resale price, and Susan Breitenbach's role, per CNBC (2019) and The Real Deal via WANE and KXAN (2021).
