By Susan Breitenbach
Whether you’re entertaining guests, planning a date night, or just want to enjoy an unforgettable meal close to home, fine dining in the Hamptons never disappoints. I’m often asked where to go for the best elevated cuisine, and over the years, I’ve built a trusted list of restaurants that consistently deliver on food, service, and experience.
Key Takeaways
- Discover five verified fine dining restaurants in the Hamptons
- Understand what makes each destination stand out
- Learn when and how to secure a reservation
- Plan meals that complement your Hamptons lifestyle
Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House – Bridgehampton
Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House offers a polished, seasonal menu that draws from the best local farms and fisheries. Located in a restored 19th-century mansion, it delivers refined dishes in a serene, upscale atmosphere without feeling overly formal. This is one of the few spots open year-round, making it a favorite for both summer guests and year-round residents.
Why It’s a Consistent Favorite
- Seasonal, farm-to-table menu crafted with local ingredients
- Stylish indoor and outdoor dining options
- Sophisticated but relaxed environment
This restaurant delivers a complete dining experience that’s both memorable and approachable. I often recommend it to clients who want elegance without pretense.
Nick & Toni’s – East Hampton
Nick & Toni’s has long been a go-to destination in East Hampton, known for its rustic charm and Mediterranean-influenced cuisine. The wood-burning oven, hand-crafted pastas, and fresh seafood make it one of the most beloved restaurants in the area. It manages to feel both upscale and warm—a rare combination that keeps people coming back.
What Sets It Apart
- Signature wood-fired dishes and Italian-inspired fare
- Long-standing local reputation with strong seasonal menus
- Casual luxury atmosphere that works for any occasion
Reservations here are essential in the summer. It’s a place where locals, celebrities, and weekend visitors all feel welcome—and where every dish is thoughtfully prepared.
1770 House Restaurant – East Hampton
For refined New American dining in a historic setting, The 1770 House remains a standout. Located inside a beautifully preserved colonial home, this restaurant offers an elegant main dining room upstairs and a more relaxed tavern downstairs. The menu is known for its focus on seasonal ingredients and elevated classics, with service that’s as thoughtful as the food.
Why It’s Worth the Visit
- Historic setting adds charm to the dining experience
- Menu changes frequently to reflect the season
- Excellent wine selection and knowledgeable staff
Clients looking for quiet luxury and timeless ambiance often choose The 1770 House. It’s perfect for anniversaries, small celebrations, or just an elevated night out in East Hampton.
flora – Westhampton Beach
On the western end of the Hamptons, flora has become a favorite for New American cuisine in a modern setting. It offers upscale dishes with a relaxed, beach-town energy that still feels special. Since opening in 2020, it’s earned strong reviews for its creative menus and high-quality ingredients.
What Makes It Stand Out
- Seasonal New American menu with coastal influences
- Casual-elegant interior with thoughtful plating and presentation
- Open year-round with reliable service in every season
I’ve recommended flora to clients looking for something less formal but still refined. It’s a great choice after a day on Dune Road or a house tour nearby.
East Hampton Grill – East Hampton
East Hampton Grill offers high-end American classics in a stylish, intimate space. Known for its steaks, fresh seafood, and signature sides, the restaurant maintains a steady following among residents who want consistently excellent meals without the scene. It doesn’t try to be flashy—it just delivers where it counts.
Why Clients Love It
- Elevated takes on classic American dishes
- Inviting atmosphere perfect for quieter dinners
- Professional service and reliably excellent food
This is one of those places where the quality speaks for itself. I’ve heard nothing but praise from clients who return again and again for its understated luxury.
FAQs
Do I need reservations at these restaurants?
Yes. Most of these restaurants book up quickly—especially during summer weekends. I always advise reserving at least a week in advance.
Are these restaurants open year-round?
Several, like Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House and flora, are open year-round. Others may reduce hours in the winter. Always confirm before making plans.
Are there dress codes at these restaurants?
While none require formalwear, most guests opt for smart-casual or business-casual attire. Think polished but relaxed—just like the Hamptons lifestyle.
Contact Me Today
Fine dining is part of the Hamptons experience, and I’m always happy to share trusted local insight—whether it’s about food, neighborhoods, or investment potential. The best meals often go hand-in-hand with the best locations, and knowing where to go helps you feel at home here faster.
If you’re thinking about buying or selling—and want a local guide who knows how to pair lifestyle with real estate—reach out to me, Susan Breitenbach. I’ll help you enjoy everything the Hamptons has to offer, starting with the next great reservation.
